Where caring comes first
It had been five months since I saw my mom last. When I walked off the train and into her arms Tuesday evening, a nostalgic wave rolled through me – I couldn’t help but tear up when I saw her face.
When we arrived at the house I plopped down on the couch in our living room, nestled between two cats, and we discussed my new home away from home.
“You sound sick,” she interjected. I agreed that I was. She warned me (for about the 10th time since I moved to NYC) to “be careful of swine flu … especially in the city. It’s going around.”
Internally rolling my eyes, I answered, “I know Mom.”
From the day I was born, my mother has always worried about my health. Days when I had a fever (or even a slight tickle in my throat or stomach ache), she’d keep me home from school. I’d spend the day on the couch while she brought me clear, carbonated beverages, soup, crackers and occasionally put the back of her hand to my forehead.
Now, as I reminisce on these moments – 24 and truly on my own/away from her for the first time in my life – I realize how lucky I was.
I realize how lucky her patients are that her caring nature is extended to them (my mom has been a registered nurse (RN) for 33 years; she’s been a nurse at Lake Shore Hospital for 17 of those years).
“So how are things with you,” I asked the question I already knew the reply to.
“Oh you know, things at work are the same,” she said simply.
I needn’t ask her what she meant. Over the past few years, I have listened to my mother and her RN friends talk about the conditions at TLC Health Network. To reiterate their complaints plainly: nurses are expected to be compassionate and caring individuals, but many members of management show little compassion to them.
In 2004, my mother found out how a union-less system works: That year, while at work, she injured her right leg and went on Workers Compensation. She went through two surgeries and has subsequently suffered permanent partial loss of use of that leg. Instead of concern she experienced fear of job loss.
Through the years, over dinners with Mom’s friends, I have heard similar stories. To my surprise, once they use up time allotted through the Family Medical Leave Act, nurses were pressured to get back to work or risk being fired.
Whereas union nurses have extended leave so they do not lose their jobs in 12 weeks.
Those nonunion nurses who grieve such issues (like my mother) have risked retaliation of having their schedules/hours changed with little or no notice. Seniority and the physical strain of being a nurse are not taken into consideration. This puts older, more experienced nurses in jeopardy, especially when they are sick or injured.
All of this is possible because the nurses at Lake Shore are considered “employees at will,” which means they can be fired without cause; policies don’t have to be followed; nepotism goes unchecked. Without a contract, this makes many afraid to voice negative opinions about the care patients receive or the conditions under which they work.
For example: RNs cannot bring up concerns about heavy patient caseloads, which leaves nurses overwhelmed and at risk for medical errors. This can jeopardize the patient as well as the nurse’s license.
In the hopes of fighting for improved treatment and benefits, my mother and others have been attempting to organize a union with SEIU at TLC since 2006.
The first union drive attempted almost four years ago was initiated because of such poor treatment of nurses by management. However, even though 70 percent of the RNs signed cards that year, the vote was stopped when the Berger Commission proposed closing the hospital.
Trying to thwart the second union drive this year, many promises and improvements have resulted as the management attempts to assuage angry RNs: new equipment that had been in short supply or poor condition was bought, benefits that were canceled were once again granted, wages that had been frozen are now being promised to be reinstated/improved.
Many nurses fear that without a union, such promises will not be maintained or fulfilled.
In addition, administration officials, anti-union employees and hired union busters attempt to mentally and physically thwart union organizers like my mother by insulting, humiliating and playing mind games to place them under added stress.
RNs at TLC voted again on Nov. 5. There were 11 challenged votes and 15 labor charges against the hospital for improprieties during the campaign, with several RNs scheduled to testify on Dec. 14 and 15. But the hospital did not want these nurses heard at a public hearing.
A re-vote will take place Jan. 7.
“Quality healthcare where caring comes first,” is the TLC Health Network mission statement.
Caring for others has always come first for my mother and most RNs I’ve met at Lake Shore. But “quality healthcare” can only exist when nurses are allowed to work in a caring environment.
Posted in A scribbling woman's Limbo
February 25th, 2010 at 7:34 pm
give me a break you have never even been to lsh to work and if your mom was so disabled she should have applied for permanent disability I see no disability on her now except laziness
February 25th, 2010 at 7:35 pm
It is amazing to me how you can write, as if you are speaking for the entire/majority of the staff at TLC, more specifically Lake Shore hospital, when in fact you are taking one persons option and adding from there. I have dedicated 20 years of my nursing career to TLC and if I were as unhappy as your mother appears I’d be finding myself a new job. It has been my experience that if you are doing what YOU ARE SUPPOSE TO YOU DON’T EVEN HAVE TO INTERACT WITH ADMINISRTION UNLESS YOU WANT TO ! ! And that is NOT just at TLC ! !
As for “the conditions at TLC” there are 900 employees that choose to stay there and many which are professionals that travel a great distance. Many that have been with TLC for15+ years, that speaks for it self. Last I knew there were no bars on the doors, and the doors swing both ways. If your mother has been so wronged by TLC why has she been there 17 years? If she wants a union why doesn’t she go work where there is ONE ? The majority of RN’s at TLC have already shown through the Vote WE DON”T WANT ONE ! !
“Heavy Case Load” 5-7 patients on average per RN. With a LPN to pass the medicines.( RN’s only pass PRN meds and IVP’s)There are 3 Nurses Aids on per shift ! ! That certainly doesn’t sound overworked to me, and furthermore a Union will have no control over the case load. As for the statement that we are “expected to be compassionate.” Back When I entered into the profession that just came FREELY, to a dedicated Nurse of the profession.
FMLA “Family Medical Leave Act” that is not a TLC guide line it is Federal ! ! NO union is going to change that ! ! What I would LOVE to KNOW even more IS . . HOW long is one job supposed to be held for ? If you work for the STATE DDSO or the STATE PRISON . . When you are off 90 days you loose your position ! ! After one year you loose your job. They have a union.
February 25th, 2010 at 7:35 pm
In an article you wrote on May 23, 2009 you stated that you enjoy lying. Also on Dec. 28, 2009 you state that you are a writer and a liar. I ask you then, how much of the information in this article is fact and how much is fiction? It is most definately a slanted view, and in my opinion parts were bordering on pure fiction or gross misinformation. There are many nurses who work at this hospital who are upset and angered by what you wrote in this article. We work at Lakeshore because we want to be there, we are not abused by management and can go to them at any time to discuss concerns that we have. I know this for fact because I have done it and had my concerns addressed. There are others who have also done the same. If a union was involved, we would have to go to them first before even going to management, and I particularly do not want a “middle man” affecting my ability to say what I want to say.